benefits
Nonlevel Premium and Benefit Policies
Nonlevel Premium and Benefit Policies
- The valuation actuary concept is a form of dynamic valuation.
- It’s becoming increasingly clear that the traditional formula-driven valuation standards cannot deal with the many variations and products, and the pace and development of new products.
- This has become more obvious to me over the last year as I’ve chaired a joint industry task force addressing reserves for nonlevel premium and benefit policies, sometimes referred to as Guideline XXX.
— Reed P. Miller, Vice President and Corporate Actuary at Lincoln National Corporation
1990 – SOA – Emerging Issues, Society of Actuaries – 38p
- This is a comment on the widely distributed Report of the Task Force on (application of the Standard Valuation and Nonforfeiture Laws to) Nonlevel Premium and Benefit Policies, made to the ACLI Actuarial Committee last April.
- The frontiers of actuarial theory interest me, so I found that document stimulating.
1980 09 – SOA – TEKEL (Dan. 5:27) – by David H. Raymond, the Actuary, Society of Actuaries – 8p
⇒ [Bonk: TEKEL = .biblegateway.com/verse/en/Daniel%205:27 – NIV – New International Version – Tekel: You have been weighed on the scales and found wanting.
FSOC – Cost Benefit Analysis
FSOC – Cost Benefit Analysis
- MetLife v FSOC – District court, Judge, Decision
- 2011 1116 – GOV (House) – Insurance Oversight and Legislative Proposals – [PDF-131p]
- (p25) – Mr. STIVERS. And the last question, I guess, for Mr. Schwarcz, given our discussion earlier about subpoena power, is there any requirement now for the FIO to do any cost-benefit analysis before they would issue a subpoena?
- Mr. SCHWARCZ. I don’t have Dodd-Frank before me right now, but I think the answer is no.
Benefits – Index
Benefits – Index
B
Blumenthal v. New York Life – 08-cv-00456 – 82-1 – Defendant Expert Witness Report – Dynamic Coverage Period Grid – p13 – 1p
LC - Blumenthal v New York Life - 82-1 - Defendant Expert Witness Report - Dynamic Coverage Period Grid - p13 - 1p
- 2008 - LC - Blumenthal v. New York Life --- [BonkNote]

Defendant Expert Report - Annual Summary Chart - p14 - 1p
Benefits – Consumer Representatives
Benefits – Consumer Representatives
- 2019 0917 – LIIIWG – Life Insurance Illustrations Issues Working Group – (A) – NAIC — [BonkNote]
- Birny Birnbaum, CEJ
|
How much do the benefits build up in the policy? How will the timing of money paid and received affect interest? |
![]() |
2018 – LIBGWG – Cude Letter / Markup Life Insurance Buyer’s Guide – Revised 2-9-18 for discussion on conference call 2-22-18
- 1994-2, NAIC Proceedings – June 13 –
- Mary Griffin (Consumers Union) – asked about Section 2 and the phase “misrepresenting the benefits of the life insurance policy.”
- She said the commissioner might already have the authority under current law to deal with misrepresentations.
- Mr. Wright directed her to the drafting note after Section 3, which discussed commissioners’ authority.
- Mary Griffin (Consumers Union) – asked about Section 2 and the phase “misrepresenting the benefits of the life insurance policy.”
Benefits – NAIC / Regulators
Benefits – NAIC – Regulators
- So I think that the NAIC is going to have to relook at the whole issue of life cost disclosure.
- It is an issue that will not go away.
- As long as the internal benefits of a policy are not reflected in the premium, people need help in measuring those benefits.
- That is, in a nutshell, what cost disclosure systems have tried to do. (p11)
— Susan Mitchell, Wisconsin Insurance Commissioner
1981 0921 – GOV (House) – Insurance Agent Commission Deregulation – [PDF-109p-GooglePlay, VIDEO-?] ->Not on govinfo.gov, Committee on Small Business – Subcommittee on General Oversight
- “future benefit illustrations”
1988-2 NAIC Proc.
- Current assumptions are critical to interest sensitive products such as Universal Life.
- When interest rates are high, benefit projections (such as cash value) are also high.
- When interest rates are low, these projections are not as attractive.
dfs.ny.gov/consumers/life_insurance/types_of_policies
- “Prospective” implies looking forward from the valuation date to future benefits the insurance company will provide and future premiums to be paid by the policyholder.
- “Retrospective” implies looking back from the valuation date to benefits already provided and premiums already paid since the contract was issued.
- Retrospective methods seem to be better suited to certain newer life insurance plans, such as universal life plans, where it is difficult to place a value on future benefits that would be provided.
1983-2, NAIC Proceedings
- Death Benefit Patterns
- This has become a complicated subject under the more flexible types of “non-traditional” policy designs which are appearing in greater numbers.
- Premium Payment Patterns
- Under non-traditional policies such as universal life and other flexible premium designs, a wide variety of premium payment patterns is available…
1986-1, NAIC Proceedings
Benefits – Actuarial
Benefits – Actuarial
- Universal life also allows for flexibility in policy benefits, not just premium payments.
2017 1115 – Letter – AAA to NAIC – LIBGWG – Re: Life Insurance Buyer’s Guide Q&A Draft 8/1/17, American Academy of Actuaries, Life Insurance Buyer’s Guide Working Group (A) – NAIC – 2p
- Maybe he is not getting all the disclosure he needs, as far as the continuing benefit is concerned, when the interest rates change from that illustrated.
— Gary P. Monnin, Senior Vice President, Chief Actuary of American Founders Life Insurance Company
1982 – SOA – Universal Life (rsa82v8n111), Society of Actuaries – 14p
- C. Universal Life
- The agent and prospect have the ability to choose almost any pattern of benefits and premiums.
- No longer is the sale limited to one of several fixed plans of insurance from a ratebook.
1991-1992 – SOA – Final Report* of the Task Force for Research on Life Insurance Sales Illustrations, Society of Actuaries – 142p
- The purpose of the “r” factor, however, is really quite simple.
- If the actual account value is less than the GMF [Guaranteed Maturity Fund], then future guaranteed policy benefits will run out before the maturity date.
- This is true because the GMF is that amount which is exactly on target to mature the policy.
- Therefore, anything less than the GMF will be insufficient to mature the policy on a guaranteed basis.
- It was felt that in order to reserve adequately for all policy guarantees, it would be desirable to make sure that any projection of benefits extends until the maturity date of the policy.
1984 – SOA – NAIC Update, Society of Actuaries – 24p
- Product designs can be complex, with benefits contingent on a range of potential risks that may vary over time, as well as with certain guarantees made by the insurer.
2009 1124 – AAA to GOV (House) (Barney Frank (D-MA) / Spencer Bachus (R-AL)) – Financial Regulatory Reform Task Force of the American Academy of Actuaries – 3p
- The typical “present value of future benefits less the present value of future net premiums” formula is challenging to apply to flexible premium universal life policies…
- …since neither “future premiums” nor “future benefits” are known for any particular policy.
2018 – Book – Statutory Valuation of Individual Life and Annuity Contracts, page 323 | 5th Edition, Claire, Lombardi and Summers
- The key to our proof was to bundle the product back up and to look at the guaranteed future benefits.
- When we did this, we made some interesting discoveries.
- Perhaps the most important was that the role of the account value and mortality and interest guarantees to define what the policy’s guaranteed death and endowment benefits are at any time.
- These elements form what we called the cost structure of the policy.
- In order to obtain a certain pattern of guaranteed benefits, how much does the policyholder have to put in his account value?
- If a company decides to charge mortality rates twice those of 1980 CSO, a larger account value is required to generate a given pattern of guaranteed benefits than would be the case if the company charges 1980 CSO rates.
- In other words, one product would be more expensive than the other.
— Michael F. Davlin
1983 – SOA – Universal Life (rsa83v9n32), Society of Actuaries – 22p
Benefits – ACLI
ACLI – Benefits
- ….provide illustrations based on different assumptions.
- This would serve to demonstrate to the consumer the effect on future benefits of changes in assumptions. (p183)
1988-2, NAIC Proceedings – ACLI – A Statement on Behalf of the American Council of Life Insurance to the NAIC Market Conduct Surveillance (EX3) Task Force – 3p

2018 0319 – ACLI – Letter – Comments on the 3-19-18 Draft Buyer’s Guide exposure draft for the Life Insurance Buyers Guide – Binder 4, p212
- …completely Dynamic services and policy opportunities for their customers to purchase and to elect a variety of options.
— Michael Lovendusky, ACLI
2019 1109 – Life Insurance Illustrations Working Group Conference Call – [Bonk: Not in Proceedings]
- re: Universal Life Insurance
- They merely afford purchasers greater flexibility in designing their contracts so as to meet their individual needs.
1982-1, NAIC Proceedings – ACLI – Statement of the American Council of Life Insurance Before the NASAA NAIC Joint Regulatory Insurance – 10p
- What is in a policy illustration?
- A policy illustration is meant to provide an example, based on certain assumptions, of how a policy’s costs and benefits may develop over time-including, but not limited to, premium amounts owed, cash values, and death benefits.
Current – ACLI – What You Should Know About Buying Life Insurance – [link]
Benefits
Benefits
- The main concern was that an unsophisticated buyer purchased a policy and did not know what the coverages, benefits and limitations were.
1988 0603 – Universal & Other New Plans (A) Task Force – NAIC – Attachment Two
1988-2, NAIC Proc.
- Maybe he is not getting all the disclosure he needs, as far as the continuing benefit is concerned, when the interest rates change from that illustrated.
— Gary P. Monnin, Senior Vice President, Chief Actuary of American Founders Life Insurance Company
1982 – SOA – Universal Life (rsa82v8n111), Society of Actuaries – 14p
|
How much do the benefits build up in the policy? How will the timing of money paid and received affect interest? |
![]() |
2018 0918 – LIBGWG (NAIC) – Brenda Cude Letter / Markup Life Insurance Buyer’s Guide – Revised 2-9-18 for discussion on conference call 2-22-18 –
- LIBGWG – Life Insurance Buyer’s Guide Working Group – (A) – NAIC — [BonkNote]
NAIC Recent Working Groups
-Cude LIBGWG? Markup – What does Benefit mean?
-Life Insurance Buyer’s Guide…. Do your Premiums or Benefits change?
- Product designs can be complex, with benefits contingent on a range of potential risks that may vary over time, as well as with certain guarantees made by the insurer.
2009 1124 – Letter – AAA to GOV (House) Barney Frank (D-MA) / Spencer Bachus (R-AL) – Financial Regulatory Reform Task Force of the American Academy of Actuaries – 3p
- Benefits – ACLI
- Benefits – Actuarial
- Benefits – Consumer Representatives
- Benefits – Industry Groups
- Benefits – NAIC / Regulators
- “benefit charges” – Universal Life Model Regulation (MDL-585)
- Chalke – Benefit Reserves, Benefit Generating Account (BGA), Benefit Generating Function (BGF),
- Current assumptions are critical to interest sensitive products such as Universal Life.
- When interest rates are high, benefit projections (such as cash value) are also high.
- When interest rates are low, these projections are not as attractive.
Accelerated Benefits
Accelerated Benefits
- 1991– SOA – Accelerated Benefits, rsa91v17n215 – Society of Actuaries – 18p
- 1991 – LR – Death and Taxes: The Taxation of Accelerated Death Benefits for the Terminally Ill, Wayne M. Gazur, University of Colorado Law School – 88p
- 1991-1A, NAIC Proceedings – Accelerated Benefits Guide Model Regulation, 12/5/1990 – Attachment Two (p544)
- (D) Disclosure of Premium Charge
- (a) Insurers with financing options other than as described in Section 10 A(2) and (3) of this regulation shall disclose to the Policyowner any premium or cost of insurance charge for the accelerated benefit.
- These insurers shall make a reasonable effort to assure that the certificate holder is aware of any additional premium coi- cost of insurance charge if the certificate holder is required to pay such charge.
- (D) Disclosure of Premium Charge

