151A - SEC - Securities and Exchange Commission

  • 2008 - SEC - sec.gov/comments/s7-14-08/s71408-1875.pdf
    • 2008 0919 - Letter - ACLI to SEC - re: Proposed Rule 151A and Proposed Rule 12h-7 - s71408 - 112p
  • 2008 1022 - CRS - Annuities and the Securities and Exchange Commission Proposed Rule 151A, RS22974
  • 2010 0729 (Updated) - CRS - Securities and Exchange Commission Rule 151A and Annuities: Issues and Legislation, Congressional Research Service - 15p
  • 2010 - SEC - sec.gov/files/rules/final/2010/33-9152.pdf
    • SUMMARY: We are withdrawing rule 151A under the Securities Act of 1933, which defines the terms "annuity contract" and "optional annuity contract" under the Act. On July 12, 2010, the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit issued an order vacating the rule.
    • EFFECTIVE DATE: Rule 151A, published at 74 FR 3175 (January 16, 2009) and effective on January 12, 2011, is withdrawn as of [INSERT DATE OF PUBLICATION IN FEDERAL REGISTER].
    • 2008 0910 - Letter - NASAA to SEC - Re: File Number S7-14-08-Comments on the SEC's Proposed Rule That Would Subject - 53p
      • Re: File Number S7-14-08-Comments on the SEC's Proposed Rule That Would Subject
        Certain Equity-Indexed Annuities to Regulation Under the Federal Securities Laws 
      • Contrary to insurance industry claims, EIAs impose significant risks upon investors, including fluctuations in the applicable equity index and potential loss of principal. In addition, issuers and agents routinely market EIAs as investments, not insurance products.

Harkin Amendment

  • 2010 1101 – Brokers World – Harkin Amendment Welcome Relief For Indexed Products, By Robert M. Elconin and Eric L. Marhoun – [link]

SEC – Regulation Best Interest – Reg BI

  • FINRA – Reg BI – [link]
  • 2008 – Report – Rand – SEC – Investor and Industry Perspectives on Investment Advisers and Broker-Dealers, Sponsored by the United States Securities and Exchange Commission – 228p

  • 2011 – Report – SEC – Study on Investment Advisers and Broker-Dealers, As Required by Section 913 of the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act – 208p
  • reginfo.gov/public/do/eAgendaViewRule?pubId=201810&RIN=3235-AM35
  • 2018 0418 – SEC – Regulation Best Interest Proposed Rule – 408p
    • 17 CFR Part 240 – Release No. 34-83062; File No. S7-07-18 – RIN: 3235-AM35
    • SUMMARY: We are proposing a new rule under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (“Exchange Act”) establishing a standard of conduct for broker-dealers and natural persons who are associated persons of a broker-dealer when making a recommendation of any securities
      transaction or investment strategy involving securities to a retail customer
  • 2018 – SEC – Comments on Proposed Rule: Regulation Best Interest – [Release No. 34-83062; File No. s7-07-18] – sec.gov/comments/s7-07-18/s70718.htm

  • 2018 0430 – SEC – Memorandum from the Office of Commissioner Hester M. Peirce regarding an April 30, 2018, meeting with representatives of the Institute for the Fiduciary Standard – 26p
    • It appears the industry is coming in this direction on the brokerage front. There is a great awareness of the importance of conflicts.
      • However, in insurance, there has not been much change from how it was twenty years ago.
  • 2018 0803 – ACLI – SEC – Re: Proposed Regulation Best Interest (“Reg. BI”) – 85p
    • 2 Since 2007, ACLI submitted input on four SEC actions concerning broker-dealers and investment adviser standards of conduct, including:
      • ACLI’s response to the SEC Chairman’s Request for Information about Standards of Conduct for
        Broker-Dealers and Investment Advisers (Oct. 3, 2017) found at https://www.sec.gov/comments/ia-bdconduct-standards/cll4-2640466-161282.pdf.
      • ACLI’s July 5, 2013 Submission in response to the SEC’s Request for Data and Information on Brokers,
        Dealers and Investment Advisers;
      • ACLI’s August 30, 2010 Submission in response to the SEC’s request for information on its Study on the Responsibilities of Brokers, Dealers, and Investment Advisers in fulfillment of Section 913 of the Dodd-Frank Act; and
      • ACLI’s December 13, 2007 Submission in response to the RAND Study on Broker-Dealer and Investment Advisory Issues.
    • ACLI’s RAND Study Submission (and those of other commentators) does not appear to be available on the SEC’s website or through RAND.
      • The RAND report included scant, if any, reference to the role life insurance Reg. BI regarding appropriate conduct standards for broker-dealers.
      • Our submission focuses on this initiative from the perspective of life insurers, their products, their distributors and their customers to ensure the regulation provides an inclusive, business model neutral framework that helps Americans achieve financial and retirement security.
      • We will also offer comments separately on Proposed Form CRS3 and the SEC’s Proposed Interpretation for Investment Adviser Standards of Conduct4 and its request for input on related questions. 
  • 2018 0926 – GOV (House) – Oversight of the SEC’s Division of Investment Management, Bill Huizenga (R-MI)
    • [PDF-43p, [VIDEO-YouTube – 01:40:14 – Starts at 31:00]
    • SEC – Dalia Blass, Director, Division of Investment Management – Testimony – p26-43
      • (p36) – Variable Insurance Product Summary Prospectus
        • Investors in variable annuities and other variable insurance products often have to navigate a complex set of disclosures about the variable contract and underlying investment options when deciding whether to invest.
        • The Division is considering a recommendation that the Commission propose rules designed to provide investors with more user-friendly, layered disclosure about variable insurance products.
        • Variable insurance products are generally more complex than other retail investment products, like mutual funds, because they combine both investment and insurance features.
        • In addition, the products typically offer a number of underlying fund investment options that have their own fees, and often include a variety of optional features, like living benefit riders that have additional charges.
        • The Division is considering whether to recommend a new summary prospectus that would help investors better understand these products’ costs and risks, and also produce cost savings that could be passed on to investors. 
    • (p1) – Huizenga – variable insurance products
    • Relationship Summary
    • financialservices.house.gov/calendar/eventsingle.aspx?EventID=408963
  • 2019 1212 – CRS – Regulation Best Interest (Reg BI): The SEC’s Rule for Broker-Dealers (R46115) – Version 1 – 29p
  • 2019 0314 – GOV (House) – Putting Investors First? Examining the SEC’s Best Interest Rule, Carolyn B. Maloney (D-NY)
    • [PDF-185p, VIDEO-YouTube-02:12:00]
    • House – Committee on Financial Services – Subcommittee on Investor Protection, Entrepreneurship, and Capital Markets
  • 2019 0605 – SEC – Regulation Best Interest: The Broker-Dealer Standard of Conduct – Final rule – 770p
    • 17 CFR Part 240, Release No. 34-86031; File No. S7-07-18
      RIN 3235-AM35

FTC - BOR - Business Opportunity Rule

  • FTC – BOR – Business Opportunity Rule  —  [BonkNote]

2000s

  • 2008 - Federal Register - FTC - Business Opportunity Rule, A Proposed Rule by the Federal Trade Commission on 03/26/2008 - [link]
    • 2008 0326 - DSA - DSA Analysis of the FTC Revised Proposed Business Opportunity Rule and What It Means for Direct Sellers, Direct Selling Association - [link]

2010s

  • 2010 1010-? - FTC - Report - Disclosure Requirements and Prohibitions Concerning Business Opportunities - Staff Report to the Federal Trade Commission and Proposed Revised Trade Regulation Rule - (16 CFR Part 437), Federal Trade Commission - 174p
  • 2011 0110 - Letter - CAI to FTC - RE: Serious problems with the latest staff report - especially in the light of new information - and a #10,000 challenge, Part 1, CAI - Consumer Awareness Institute - 8p
    • In your staff report posted in October on the FTC web site on the proposed Business Opportunity Rule, we find the following...
    • 2010 1010-? - FTC - Report - Disclosure Requirements and Prohibitions Concerning Business Opportunities - Staff Report to the Federal Trade Commission and Proposed Revised Trade Regulation Rule - (16 CFR Part 437), Federal Trade Commission - 174p
  • 2011 - Federal Register - FTC - Business Opportunity Rule, A Rule by the Federal Trade Commission on 12/08/2011 - [link]
  • 2019 1203 - FTC - Report - The Alchemy of a Pyramid: Transmutating business opportunity into a negative sum wealth transfer, by Andrew Stivers, Federal Trade Commission - 33p

2020s

  • 2021 0614 - FTC - Press Release - Statement of Commissioner Rohit Chopra - Regarding the Business Opportunity Rule - Commission File No. P924214, Federal Trade Commission - 2p

Life Insurance Caucus

  • Financial Protection and Life Insurance Caucus
    • 2015 0508 – Reuters -Insurers step up lobbying to battle U.S. regulators, By Douwe Miedema – [link]
      • “The new caucus will be instrumental in solidifying congressional support for our industry, particularly in helping to elevate our industry’s profile,” American Council of Life Insurers Chief Executive Dirk Kempthorne said in a March 10 email to members that was obtained by Reuters. – [ACLI]
      • Richard Neal and Pat Tiberi, both members of the powerful House Ways and Means Committee, which regulates taxes, are co-chairs of the newly established insurance caucus. Both have received large sums of money for their campaigns from the industry in recent years, public data shows.

Orderly Resolution Authority

  • AIG’s problems “highlight the need for a resolution authority with the power to manage the orderly restructuring of a large, complex, non-bank financial institution that poses a threat to the stability of our financial system,” Geithner said.

2009 0324 – ThinkAdvisor – Geithner To Ask For More Powers, By Arthur D. Postal – [link] 

  • (p7) – Joseph TORTI, NAIC, Deputy Director and Superintendent of Insurance and Banking, Rhode Island Department of Business Regulation:
    • I hope I understand your question. Are you saying as a result of the Dodd-Frank changes that have been made, what would be done differently?
  • Al GREEN (D-TX) – How would the States respond to the FDIC handling exigent circumstances comparable to AIG during the financial crisis?
  • Mr. TORTI. The traditional way that we would handle that type of thing is we try to create a wall around the insurance entity to protect the insurance entity and the insurance entity’s policyholders from those circumstances so that the insurance policyholders and claimants aren’t made to pay for the problems outside the insurance entity.
    • That is normally the way that we protect an insurance entity in a receivership situation.
    • So if there were a holding company issue or a significant affiliate outside of the insurance entity that had financial difficulties, we would protect the insurer from those financial difficulties through the current receivership laws that we have in all the States.
  • Mr. GREEN. In essence, are you saying that you would be able to work within the confines of Dodd-Frank and with the FDIC so as to perfect an orderly liquidation?
  • Mr. TORTI. We really hope we don’t end up in that situation again.
  • Mr. GREEN. Obviously, yes, I concur.
  • Mr. TORTI. But, yes, we believe we should be able to work with the FDIC.
    • We are hopeful that we will be able to work with the FDIC.
    • We have a very good relationship with the FDIC.
    • The FDIC has acknowledged that protection of the policyholders and claimants of the insurance entity is of utmost importance to us, and we believe that we should be able to work with them on that type of circumstance.
  • Mr. GREEN. Are there any technical changes to the draft we have that you would recommend to help to facilitate this?
  • Mr. TORTI. I can’t think of any technical changes that I would offer to the current draft that you have, no.

2011 1116 – GOV (House) – Insurance Oversight and Legislative Proposals, Judy Biggert (R-IL) – [PDF-131p – VIDEO-?]

UILA – Uniform Insurers Liquidation Act

  • 1940 – LR – Legislation: The Uniform Insurers Liquidation Act – 12p
  • 1953 – LR – The Uniform Insurers Liquidation Act and Wisconsin Law, by Darrell L. Peck – 10p
  • 1940 – LR – Legislation: The Uniform Insurers Liquidation Act – 12p
    • Corporations doing business in several states have long faced the problem of ancillary receiverships when forced into insolvency.
      • Because of limited extraterritorial powers of receivers, delinquency has produced a series of diversified liquidation proceedings, which have in turn wreaked
        havoc with the affairs of the company.’
      • Although there has been a vast improvement in national bankruptcy legislation, with the passage of the Chandler Act in 1938,2 so that the receivership device has been abandoned to a large degree by most corporations, insurance companies have been excluded from the Act.3
        • Consequently, they must still rely upon receivership and local statutory substitutes for insolvency proceedings.
      • To cope with the continued existence of the many problems of decentralization, and the expense and delay of ancillary receiverships still necessary for insurers, the Uniform Act was adopted.4 
      • Like most uniform legislation, the Act attempts to cover a broad field.
      • If it is to be extensively used, it must afford remedies for problems that have defied solution for a long time.
      • In order to evaluate its efficiency, therefore, it is necessary to compare the existing law with the new provisions that are embodied in the Act.

FIGC – Federal Insurance Guaranty Corporation

United States vs. South-Eastern Underwriters Association

  • 1944 – LC – UNITED STATES v. SOUTH-EASTERN UNDERWRITERS ASSOCIATION (SEUA) ET AL., APPEAL FROM THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF GEORGIA., No. 354. Argued January 11, 1944.-Decided June 5, 1944 – 63p

Insurance Information Act

  • H.R. 5840 – The Insurance Information Act of 2008
    • Paul Kanjorski (D-PA) – (Introduced 04/17/2008)
      Committees: House – Financial Services
  • H.R.2609 – Insurance Information Act of 2009
    • Paul Kanjorski (D-PA) – (Introduced 05/21/2009)
    • Committees: House – Financial Services
  • 2008 0610 – GOV (House) – H.R. 5840, The Insurance Information Act of 2008, Paul Kanjorski (D-PA)  —  [BonkNote]
    • [PDF-129p, VIDEO-?] – R
    • Kanjorski, McRaith, Rahn, Stephen E., Vice President and Associate General Counsel, Lincoln Financial Group, on behalf of the American Council of Life Insurers (ACLI)
    • AAA – American Academy of Actuaries – 2008 0729 – 2p
    • AIA – 2008 0610 – 7p
    • NCOIL – (p14) – Brian P. Kennedy, Representative, Rhode Island House of Representatives, and President, National Conference of Insurance Legislator – 2008 0611 – 2p
    • DOTT – 2008 0610 – 3p
    • House – Committee on Financial Services – Subcommittee on Capital Markets, Insurance, and Government Sponsored Enterprises
  • 2008 0708 – Letter – NAIC – re HR 5840 – 2p
  • 2008 0729 – Letter – AAA, American Academy of Actuaries – re HR 5840 – 2p
    • On behalf of the Financial Regulatory Reform Task Force of the American Academy of Actuaries1, I strongly encourage you to explicitly define the role of the actuary in this legislation.
      • Ensuring that the actuary maintains a key role in any potential federal regulatory structure for insurance is fundamental to the objective of protecting insurance consumers and preserving the financial integrity of the industry.
    • 2003 – Report – AAA – Role of the Actuary Under Federal Insurance Regulation, Public Policy Monograph, American Academy of Actuaries – 20p
  • 2008 0912 – Letter – Maine – Bureau of Insurance – re H.R. 5840 – The Insurance Information Act of 2008 – 2p
  • 2008 0915 – Letter – CEJ, Public Citizen, U.S. PIRG * Center for Economic Justice, Consumer Federation of California – re HR 5840 – 3p
  • (p3) – Brad SHERMAN (D-CA). I think the Federal Government needs to have expertise on insurance.
    • I see a Federal Office of Insurance as posing both one opportunity and one danger or concern.

2008 0610 – GOV (House) – H.R. 5840, The Insurance Information Act of 2008, Paul Kanjorski (D-PA)  —  [BonkNote]