1978 1112 - NP - The Atlanta Constitution - New 'Deposit Term' Insurance Creating Uproar in Industry - [A.L. Williams], by Joe Ledlie

12 Nov 1978, Sun The Atlanta Constitution (Atlanta, Georgia) Newspapers.com

12 Nov 1978, Sun The Atlanta Constitution (Atlanta, Georgia) Newspapers.com

Hyperfunding

Nonlevel Premium and Benefit Policies

  • The valuation actuary concept is a form of dynamic valuation.
  • It’s becoming increasingly clear that the traditional formula-driven valuation standards cannot deal with the many variations and products, and the pace and development of new products.
  • This has become more obvious to me over the last year as I’ve chaired a joint industry task force addressing reserves for nonlevel premium and benefit policies, sometimes referred to as Guideline XXX.

—  Reed P. Miller, Vice President and Corporate Actuary at Lincoln National Corporation

1990 – SOA – Emerging Issues, Society of Actuaries – 38p

  • This is a comment on the widely distributed Report of the Task Force on (application of the Standard Valuation and Nonforfeiture Laws to) Nonlevel Premium and Benefit Policies, made to the ACLI Actuarial Committee last April.
  • The frontiers of actuarial theory interest me, so I found that document stimulating.

1980 09 – SOA – TEKEL (Dan. 5:27) – by David H. Raymond, the Actuary, Society of Actuaries – 8p

⇒  [Bonk: TEKEL = .biblegateway.com/verse/en/Daniel%205:27 – NIV – New International Version – Tekel: You have been weighed on the scales and found wanting.

Premium Calculation

  • When it offers a plan of insurance for a specified premium it does so on the basis of an expected level of mortality, interest, withdrawal, expense and taxation in the future.
    • It also recognizes that the future experience levels will vary from those expected at issue through statistical variability or through long term or cyclical trends and sets its premiums to make allowances  for this variability.
    • As the experience under the plan unfolds the company can release into earnings the differences between the provisions in the premiums for variability and actual variations experienced to date.
    • The instrument for accomplishing this is the reserve and, specifically, the release from risk reserve system is based on this concept.

1974 – SOA – Report of the Historian – Special Report, Society of Actuaries – 116p

  • One thing to keep in mind is that you can take a traditional whole life policy and determine an underlying benefit generating function, because the cash values are simply there.
    • You can fix one item and say, “We are charging 1980 CSO mortality and 6% interest,” and then solve for the effective nonforfeiture net premium.

—  Douglas DOLL

1989 – SOA – Status Report on Standard Nonforfeiture Law Revisions, Society of Actuaries – 14p

1976 – SOA – Toward Adjustable Individual Life Products, Society of Actuaries, by Walter L. Chapin – 50p

  • [Bonk – Grading, Interest Rate, PVFB=PVFP, Mortality – Term higher than Perm]
  • Samuel P. Adams: All these methods are based one way or another on the ancient truth that the present value of benefits, expenses, and margins must equal the present value of premiums.
    • When one considers the interest assumption, it must be remembered that rates are presently very high but may be showing signs of leveling off.
      • It seems inconceivable in view of the past that interest rates will stay at their present levels for a long period of time.
      • If the interest assumption in the early policy years is taken as the rate on new investments, the actuary should allow for the possibility of a reduction after the first few policy years and provide for a more conservative rate at the later policy durations.
  • CHAIRMAN Robert W. WALKER: We also recognize the difference between term and permanent mortality with a higher mortality charge on term contracts.
  • RUSSELL E. MUNRO: We also develop our rate structure so as to reimburse our agency force on a basis which does not place the agent in an awkward position in his recommendations for his client cost per $1,000 at risk.

1968 – SOA – Premiums and Dividends for Individual Ordinary Insurance, Society of Actuaries – 30p

  • 1987 – SOA – Life Insurance Transformations, by Douglas A. Eckley, tsa87v395 – Society of Actuaries – 22p

BGA – Benefit Generating Account

  • This creature called universal life has evolved from a combination of term insurance and a flexible premium annuity to a range of differing products with various design features.
    • Common to any of these variations is the fact that future cash values cannot be determined completely at issue.
    • Cash values (and other benefits) are produced by a formula that is specified in advance. Some of the various elements used in the formula, however, can be adjusted after issue by the insurer. 
  • 6. THE CONCEPT OF THE BENEFIT GENERATING ACCOUNT
    • We have mentioned several times that the function of the account value is to determine future benefits. 

1983 – SOA – Universal Life Valuation and Nonforfeiture: A Generalized Model, Shane A. Chalke and Michael F. Davlin, Society of Actuaries – 72p

BGF – Benefit Generating Function

  • BGA – Benefit Generating Account
  • BGF – Benefit Generating Function
  • Premium Calculation
  • One thing to keep in mind is that you can take a traditional whole life policy and determine an underlying benefit generating function, because the cash values are simply there.
    • You can fix one item and say, “We are charging 1980 CSO mortality and 6% interest,” and then solve for the effective nonforfeiture net premium.

—  Douglas DOLL

1989 – SOA – Status Report on Standard Nonforfeiture Law Revisions, Society of Actuaries – 14p

  • 6. THE CONCEPT OF THE BENEFIT GENERATING ACCOUNT (BGA)
    • We have mentioned several times that the function of the account value is to determine future benefits.
    • Again we stress the fact that the account value may bear no simple relation to the reserve or the cash value required by law.
    • For this reason (and to avoid confusion) we will refer to the account value as the benefit generating account (BGA). This term aptly describes the account value’s primary purpose.
    • The set of rules that determine the guaranteed benefits that the BGA will produce we will refer to as the benefit generating function (BGF).
    • The BGF includes such items as the method of determining the term charge and amount at risk, the portion of the gross premium credited to the BGA, the method by which BGAs accumulate, and those policy guarantees defining future minimum BGAs. The portion of the gross premium actually credited to the BGA we will term the BGF premium.
    • If we restate the three necessary conditions for the Classical UL Model in terms of the BGA and the BGF, they become the following:

1983 – SOA – Universal Life Valuation and NonForfeiture: A Generalized Model, by Shane A. Chalke and Michael Davlin, Society of Actuaries – 72p

  • CHARLES E. RITZKE: I, too, agree in principle about Mr. Doll’s prospective approach being the most appropriate.
    • One concern I would have is the elements of the benefit generating function.
    • When you start talking about regulating elements of benefit generating functions, it is important also to find a benefit generating function for traditional products and regulate the same functions and the same pieces in order to maintain a level playing field.
  • Douglas DOLL: One thing to keep in mind is that you can take a traditional whole life policy and determine an underlying benefit generating function, because the cash values are simply there.
    • You can fix one item and say, “We are charging 1980 CSO mortality and 6% interest,” and then solve for the effective nonforfeiture net premium.

1989 – SOA – Status Report on Standard Nonforfeiture Law Revisions, Society of Actuaries – 14p

Premium Payment Options

  • The complications begin with a very simple question:
  • What's the premium for Universal Life?
    • It could be almost anything.
  • Then what's the cash value?
    • That depends on the premium.
  • It is the relationship between the premium and cash value that determines the product characteristics of Universal Life.

--  Ben H. Mitchell, [Bonk: a consulting actuary with Tillinghast in Atlanta - Years-?]

1981 - SOA - Universal Life, Society of Actuaries - 16p

  • The agent and prospect have the ability to choose almost any pattern of benefits and premiums.
  • No longer is the sale limited to one of several fixed plans of insurance from a ratebook.

1991-1992 - SOA - Final Report* of the Task Force for Research on Life Insurance Sales Illustrations, Society of Actuaries  ---  [BonkNote]

  • Universal Life Modeling Example
  • Funding Levels 
    • Universal life plans offer the policyholder great flexibility in their use of the plan -- from a term plan to an investment vehicle.
  • The funding level affects:
    • 1. Universal life commissioners reserve valuation method reserves -- In particular the r factor is the ratio of the actual fund value to the guaranteed maturity fund.
    • Since r is capped at 100%, using a ratio based on the average fund for all policies may not produce the actual reserve.

1994 - SOA - Valuation Actuary Symposium - Session 8 - Life and Deferred Annuity Liability Models - Society of Actuaries - 32p

  • Example 2 - The following table represents the assumptions for this example: back-end load universal life policy; $100,000 specified amount, death benefit option A; insured is a male, age 50, non-smoker; credited rate is 8. 75%; and six premium levels, shown below.
  • Premium Level Description
    • A - IRC Section 7702 Guideline Single Premium ($32,766.82).
    • B - IRC Section 7702 Guideline Level Premium ($3,083.55).
    • C - Target Premium of $1,374 years 1 to 20.
    • D - Target Premium of $1,374 years 1 to 10, $0 years 11 to 20.
    • E - Target Premium of $1,374 years 1 to 5, $0 years 6 to 15, and $1,200 years 16 to 20.
    • F - "ART" premium scenario, i.e. target premium in years 1 and 2 followed by minimum premium to keep policy in force.

1988-2, NAIC Proceedings 

  • Many insurance contracts offer the policyowner options regarding premium payment, benefit patterns, and policy loans.
  • This flexibility means that many different patterns of future cash flow could arise under the contract. (p6)

2002 09 - AAA - Fair Valuation of Insurance Liabilities: Principles and Method, American Academy of Actuaries - 48p

  • Carriers marketed interest rate-sensitive insurance under a host of premium payment options, including the `vanishing premium' plan.

2009 -  LC - Kaldenbach v. Mutual of Omaha - Court of Appeals of California, Fourth District, Division Three. 78 Cal.App.4th 830 (2009) 100 Cal.Rptr.3d 637 - Google Scholar-Kaldenbach-2009

  • Persons seeking life insurance for the Whole of Life have several choices: they may...
    1. buy a one-year renewable term contract and renew it annually, paying the full cost of insurance for each year
    2. buy coverage for the insured's life with a single premium payment, or 
    3. buy coverage for the whole of life under some type of installment arrangement.  (p47)

1984 - Book - Life Insurance: Theory and Practice, Robert I. Mehr

 

Underfunded Life Insurance Policies

  • “under funded” “life insurance”
  • Impactful Ideas to Promote Ethics Awareness
  • Small Group Case Study Discussions
    • Use Real (Sanitized) Cases From Your Own Company
    • Supplement With Industry Challenges (e.g. Underfunded Universal Life Insurance Policies and What Steps Company Compliance & Ethics Professionals Can Take to Help Their Companies Address this Issue)

2019 1025 – ACLI / CEFLI – Meeting the Challenge of Promoting Ethics, Kelly Ireland, Vice President – Compliance & Ethics, Compliance & Ethics Forum for Life Insurers – 29p

  • 2008 – Letter (Example) Conseco – Change of COI Letter Example to Client Conseco -Ltr_to_PHs_102708 – 8p 

Black Box

  • 1996 – SOA – The Actuarial Black Box, by Sam Gutterman, The Actuary, act-1996-vol30-iss01-gutterman-b – Society of Actuaries – 2p 
  • 2009 0305 – WSJ – AIG’s Black Box The fourth rescue is not a charm, by Author-? – [link]
  • What UL does, among other things, is to let the policyowner or maybe the agent pick the point on the line between these two promises— pick the point that best fits the situation that the agent or the policyowner is in.
    • He can have a high premium policy with lots of dividends if experience does remain good
    • or he can pay a very low premium but have a big risk of increasing the premium if experience does not turn out so well.
    • One thing this ability does, it opens up the traditional 3-factor dividend formula, the black box, so that some of the workings are exposed.
      • That is the good side, the opening up of the black box.

— Bruce E. Booker

1988 – SOA – Update on Universal Life Reserves and Non-Forfeiture Values, Society of Actuaries – 36p

  • A. The Black Box of Life Insurance
    • 6. Life insurance contracts are circular, interrelated series of cash flows into, out of, and within a policy.
    • There are innumerable ways to establish these cash flows…

—  Declaration of Robert E. Wilcox  in Opposition to Plaintiff’s Motion for Class Certification – Former Utah Insurance Commissioner and Chairman of the Life Disclosure Working Group (NAIC)

2012 0313 – LC – Thao v Midland, United States District Court Eastern District of Wisconsin, 2:09-C-1158-LA, Filed 02/11/11, Page 1 of 44 

Premiums, Costs, Values and Benefits – Lawsuits

  • Mr. Pickens and Cowboy Athletics, a fund-raising arm of the university, contend that the Lincoln National Life Insurance Company understated the costs of the program, overstated its potential financial benefits and charged the university inflated premiums, among other things.

2010 0212 – WSJ – University and Pickens Sue Over Fund-Raising Plan, by Stephanie Storm – [link]